Last updated: 29 July 2026
Quick Comparison
| Feature | Economybookings.com | GetRentacar.com |
|---|---|---|
| Coverage | 150+ countries, 20,000+ pickup locations worldwide | 80 countries with active listings — strongest in Europe and CIS |
| Best For | Travelers who want to compare the widest range of options in one search | Adventurous travelers seeking unique local rental experiences at rock-bottom prices |
Mainstream Aggregator vs Peer-to-Peer Disruptor
Economybookings represents the established car rental comparison model — 800+ commercial suppliers searched simultaneously. GetRentacar disrupts this by adding private car owners to the mix, creating a marketplace where a personal BMW competes on price against fleet Toyotas. These are fundamentally different products serving different risk-reward profiles.
Price Reality
| Route | Economybookings | GetRentacar | Analysis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Split SPU, August | €155 | €110 | GetRentacar: private owner Mercedes |
| Antalya AYT, July | €120 | €68 | GetRentacar: local agency, 43% cheaper |
| New York JFK, May | €190 | Not available | US market: Economybookings only |
| Tbilisi, September | €60 | €38 | GetRentacar strong in Caucasus |
Where GetRentacar operates, it's consistently 25–45% cheaper than Economybookings — the peer-to-peer model genuinely undercuts commercial pricing. But GetRentacar's geographic coverage is much narrower, concentrated in Southern/Eastern Europe and the Caucasus. In the Americas, Northern Europe, and Asia-Pacific, Economybookings wins by being the only viable option.
Reliability vs Adventure
Economybookings delivers a predictable experience: you know you're renting from a commercial company with a physical location, fleet insurance, and a standardized process. The tradeoff is higher prices and the potential for insurance upsells at the counter.
GetRentacar's peer-to-peer listings are an adventure by comparison. You might get a newer, better car than you'd find in any rental fleet. You might meet the owner at your hotel for a personal handover with local tips. Or you might deal with an owner who's running late and communicates poorly. The ratings system helps, but there's inherent variance in peer-to-peer transactions.
When the Choice Is Clear
Economybookings, no question: US rentals, UK rentals, Northern Europe, any destination where GetRentacar has zero or limited coverage, and corporate/business travel where predictability is non-negotiable.
GetRentacar, worth trying: Croatia, Montenegro, Turkey, Georgia, Armenia, and other markets where its peer-to-peer inventory offers dramatic savings — as long as you're comfortable with a less corporate rental experience.
Check both: Mainland Spain, Greece, Italy — both have strong coverage, and the cheapest option depends entirely on specific dates and cities.
Frequently Asked Questions
More Comparisons
Compare Both Directly
Prices move constantly. Run the same dates on each and take the lower total, including insurance and deposit.
Check Economybookings.com Prices → Check GetRentacar.com Prices →