Quick Comparison
| Feature | Economybookings.com | GetRentacar.com |
|---|---|---|
| Coverage | 160+ countries, 50,000+ pickup locations worldwide | Growing network, strongest in Europe and CIS countries |
| Best For | Travelers who want to compare the widest range of options in one search | Adventurous travelers seeking unique local rental experiences at rock-bottom prices |
| Commission Rate | 3–8% | 10% |
| Cookie Lifetime | 30 days | 30 days |
Mainstream Aggregator vs Peer-to-Peer Disruptor
Economybookings represents the established car rental comparison model — 800+ commercial suppliers searched simultaneously. GetRentacar disrupts this by adding private car owners to the mix, creating a marketplace where a personal BMW competes on price against fleet Toyotas. These are fundamentally different products serving different risk-reward profiles.
Price Reality
| Route | Economybookings | GetRentacar | Analysis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Split SPU, August | €155 | €110 | GetRentacar: private owner Mercedes |
| Antalya AYT, July | €120 | €68 | GetRentacar: local agency, 43% cheaper |
| New York JFK, May | €190 | Not available | US market: Economybookings only |
| Tbilisi, September | €60 | €38 | GetRentacar strong in Caucasus |
Where GetRentacar operates, it's consistently 25–45% cheaper than Economybookings — the peer-to-peer model genuinely undercuts commercial pricing. But GetRentacar's geographic coverage is much narrower, concentrated in Southern/Eastern Europe and the Caucasus. In the Americas, Northern Europe, and Asia-Pacific, Economybookings wins by being the only viable option.
Reliability vs Adventure
Economybookings delivers a predictable experience: you know you're renting from a commercial company with a physical location, fleet insurance, and a standardized process. The tradeoff is higher prices and the potential for insurance upsells at the counter.
GetRentacar's peer-to-peer listings are an adventure by comparison. You might get a newer, better car than you'd find in any rental fleet. You might meet the owner at your hotel for a personal handover with local tips. Or you might deal with an owner who's running late and communicates poorly. The ratings system helps, but there's inherent variance in peer-to-peer transactions.
When the Choice Is Clear
Economybookings, no question: US rentals, UK rentals, Northern Europe, any destination where GetRentacar has zero or limited coverage, and corporate/business travel where predictability is non-negotiable.
GetRentacar, worth trying: Croatia, Montenegro, Turkey, Georgia, Armenia, and other markets where its peer-to-peer inventory offers dramatic savings — as long as you're comfortable with a less corporate rental experience.
Check both: Mainland Spain, Greece, Italy — both have strong coverage, and the cheapest option depends entirely on specific dates and cities.